I have had an influx of these game decomps on my Instagram recently and was wondering why so many were appearing out of nowhere. Shortly after that influx, the open-sourcing Adobe Suit thing happened and again its on my feed. Most of these projects use AI to make it easier to decomply these things and understand why it was used but I am a bit worried about the implications. As in, will these decomps actually be stable? Will they be maintained? Will companies start lobbying for AI laws harder now, in a way it benefits them and not us?
I personally stay away from AI due to the many issues AI brings but I am a fan of people fighting big companies but is this the way to do it?
Do we know this is decompilation? The Adobe Suite one seems to be more a replication of form and function than a true decompilation of the existing software. The interface is easy to replicate, and then each tool and function within it is being recreated based on what it does. The project themselves claim that is how they’ve done it, and it’s feasible. It also seems to be entirely legal.
Whether it is right or wrong, it really brings into focus how the copyright laws are. They’ve been used to bash individual end users for decades, but now we’re seeing they actually seem to have no effect on the AI companies stealing vast troves of data to train their models. We’re also seeing that the tools can be used to do perfectly legal things that have been done manually for decades in the open source community. You can copyright specific code, but you can’t copyright a specific GUI or broad function.
I’m doubt when companies were jumping on to the AI band wagon that they envisioned that AI could be used to totally undermine all the “value” they’d built in their businesses with proprietary software that was just too difficult to replicate. Now it seems to be so extremely easy to replicate that proprietary software in general may be in serious trouble as a business model.
I’ve played with the storycraft tools; it’s actually mindboggling how functional they are with 10 projects that all are already at alpha software level, and useable for basic tasks. Whether or not these projects actually come to fruition is kinda irrelevant; we’ve been shown it can be done and with surprising ease.