I’ve recently heard some AI Music that is objectively just good.
Like it sounds real, feels real, the lyrics have deep meaning, and so on. I hate it, and wish it didn’t exist. But fact is “I hate AI art because it’s bad art” just doesn’t really make sense anymore. You can hate it for many other reasons but the quality of the product is very good.
I don’t have to. Wikipedia has a good enough definition:
Art is a diverse range of cultural activity centered around works utilizing creative or imaginative talents, which are expected to evoke a worthwhile experience, generally through an expression of emotional power, conceptual ideas, technical proficiency, or beauty.
An LLM generating output isn’t “cultural activity” no matter how much that concept could be tortured, and it doesn’t have “creative or imaginative talents”, because it isn’t sapient or sentient.
Nah idk, people usually say separate Art from the Artist but I genuinely think that doesnt always apply even if it Applied Most of the time. Think dxvid who impregnated and killed Off a Minor: I thought his music was okay and then After hearing what he did I literally cant listen to his music anymore even tho I would still listen to other controversial artists (say, the kill from jared leto, although I started listening less to it).
My point is even the dumbest fucking idiot can make what you call „quality“ slop so why would you listen to their stuff & look at their Art when you can do it yourself instead of supporting a fucking idiot
I’ve recently heard some AI Music that is objectively just good.
Like it sounds real, feels real, the lyrics have deep meaning, and so on. I hate it, and wish it didn’t exist. But fact is “I hate AI art because it’s bad art” just doesn’t really make sense anymore. You can hate it for many other reasons but the quality of the product is very good.
No, it’s because it isn’t art.
Good luck with that.
Define art for me?
I don’t have to. Wikipedia has a good enough definition:
An LLM generating output isn’t “cultural activity” no matter how much that concept could be tortured, and it doesn’t have “creative or imaginative talents”, because it isn’t sapient or sentient.
So true babe, ai certainly has had 0.0 cultural impact
Nah idk, people usually say separate Art from the Artist but I genuinely think that doesnt always apply even if it Applied Most of the time. Think dxvid who impregnated and killed Off a Minor: I thought his music was okay and then After hearing what he did I literally cant listen to his music anymore even tho I would still listen to other controversial artists (say, the kill from jared leto, although I started listening less to it).
My point is even the dumbest fucking idiot can make what you call „quality“ slop so why would you listen to their stuff & look at their Art when you can do it yourself instead of supporting a fucking idiot