I think i see the two senses of where the miscommunication occurred.
You can put psychoanalysis in the same bucket at homeopathy in that it doesn’t work when studied by clinical trials, and mainstream practitioners don’t use it.
On the other hand, Freud was not trying to be fraudulent, and did contribute tremendously to the field of psychology, unlike homeopathy’s fraudulent relationship to medicine.
I think i see the two senses of where the miscommunication occurred.
You can put psychoanalysis in the same bucket at homeopathy in that it doesn’t work when studied by clinical trials, and mainstream practitioners don’t use it.
On the other hand, Freud was not trying to be fraudulent, and did contribute tremendously to the field of psychology, unlike homeopathy’s fraudulent relationship to medicine.
Exactly that’s the overall sentiment. I personally see it that way too.