Today, I am wondering if Generative AI is one of the reasons that I started feeling aimless in my job as a researcher.

I work a lot with data in various forms and in the process of data analysis and preparation, I have started to rely quite a lot on the use of LLMs to do tasks for me that would otherwise be tedious and but represented a large share in what i was doing before. Last week, I was tasked to understand, structure, and organise a complex administrative data set with bad documentation, and unclear temporal coherency to make it available for analysis.

This would have been a challenging task some years ago. Maybe a week or two spent, focused on reading articles that have used the data set for other purposes, browsing documentation texts, looking up code bits on stackoverflow.

Instead, now, i bit by bit feed my instructions into an LLM trying to make sure it does the right things and provides the necessary documentation to keep the code sensible and human readable. But basically, I give a task, wait 20 minutes while the machine bobbles along, review what it had done, understand possible problems, set the next task, and then wait again.

In the in-between, I open a game of chess, or browse some articles (even interesting ones).

I can spend many hours like this, and usually finish the task quicker than i would have doing all the work by myself, or with an LLM of 3 years ago, where all code planning, and downloading was still done by hand, the LLM just helped me writing code blocks and syntax.

And I am wondering, if there is anything to do about this. Practically.

Because going back to the old world of doing 90 percent of the work (or even 100 percent), does not seem sensible from a pace perspective.

Yet, I also feel kind of empty while doing the task.

I am curious how other people have been in similar situation.

(I would like to propose to not make this a conversation about the ecological or ethical downsides of GenAI. They are real and relevant, yet, maybe this conversation can be more about the personal experience of LLM use)

  • starelfsc2@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    1 day ago

    I think one factor is that we inherently value things that took time, annoyance, or effort. If I bring you a glass of water that I ran over 3 mountains to give you, you’re going to be careful not to spill it, even though that water is the same as if I walked 2 feet to the tap.

    With work I think it’s the same, it’s cool to get more done, but each thing feels less valuable because less was put into it. We value having something to struggle against, and we can still do what we used to before AI, but like you said it’s no longer needed or efficient, so there’s nothing pushing us to do it.

    Add on the fact that guiding AI isn’t really hard, it’s just annoying most of the time, and you’ve traded validating work where you accomplished something, for being a babysitter to a computer.

    I read something that imo brings back that value of doing it manually sometimes, that being even doing grunt work gives familiarity and practice, and that gives you more insights for the harder problems. It’s like if you had a car engine repair AI, sometimes you should still do it yourself to keep yourself familiar with the process, mistakes that might happen, what it should look like. For me that’s enough of a point to keep coding, all the not so obvious expertise and insight you gain along the way is extremely valuable.

    • Ohlalala@feddit.orgOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 day ago

      This makes a lot of sense. There was a lot of validation in creating something or solving a problem that could only be achieved through focus and determination. But importantly, something that also had an actual solution. A lot of my work was about doing something hard that would bear fruits like a nice map, some new insight, or an elegant analysis.

      Now most of what remains are problems that cannot really be answered through focus, but just infinite layers of social reality and philosophical problems.

      Maybe it could be interesting to ask if it could be possible to find a new set of problems that are more similar to the data work of before.