This post was deleted by an admin (ground: not archeology). I want to understand , how they decide, what is or is not allowed, in the community I created. especially when they had no problem with another meme/history post : https://sopuli.xyz/post/54498758, https://sopuli.xyz/post/53153470, https://sopuli.xyz/post/52558875 … I dont want to say it is abject censure, but it is.

I never had complaint so far on sopuli so I want to know where they come from. Is there some instance, where admin, let you decide what you allow or not in your com?

Edit: I contacted the sopuli admin, will report how it unfold

edit2: After a few back and forth with admin of the instance, it was reinstated. Still dont know why it was deleted on the first place. Make me feel unease with the instance. So if you know cool, no delete heavy instance, where the admin wont overstep over a mod ruling its comm (outside instance rule breaking); I will look into them to migrate

  • Pamasich@kbin.earth
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    3 days ago

    Looks like PTB to me.

    The user is complaining about a post they made to their own community getting removed by their instance admin on the grounds of not being about archaeology. Not because of an instance rule. The admin is not also a mod of this community, OP is the sole mod.

    It’s worth noting that while the community is named “acheology”, the description defines it quite differently: “Everything about old history and how to get information about old time”

    So the admin is strolling in uninvited and removing a post due to a very strict interpretation of just the community’s title, disregarding the description. And also not applying that universally to other posts.

    In my opinion, regardless of intention, that’s clear overreach. This community isn’t their responsibility beyond the instance rules, and they do not understand its rules. They’re not even trying to understand them, just reading the title and nothing else and that’s all they go by. Even if we assume it wasn’t malicious and just the admin trying to help out with moderation, that’s some real half-assed and irresponsible way to do that and shows why they really should have at least asked for permission in that case. Even if this really was an offtopic post, it’s not the admin’s job to remove it if it’s not breaking instance rules.

    I do think the fact this is the only removed post suggests political reasoning, but I wouldn’t jump to it based on one case. Either way, even if it wasn’t malicious, this shouldn’t be a thing.