I have tried that with a small side project - a simple TUI app and parser in Rust - and I wasn’t convinced it is really faster. It spat out some 4,000 lines in about four afternoons, a bit of ratatui and so on. The cursor wasn’t visible. The fix was completely hallucinated, or BS, and suggested downloading and patching another lib. The parser was incorrect. It had over one hundred dependencies. I could fix it with two or three more afternoons time. Now, 4000 lines in a few days still sounds impressive, doesn’t it?
But then, I wanted to know it, threw the generated code away, and wrote it again from scratch. I got there with half the code and had it working. In the same time. With a working cursor and a better parser.
I think the speed perception is like when you are using public transport or a commuter train vs a bicycle. The motorized vehicle always feels faster. But at distances like ten miles / 15 kilometers, it isn’t. A car still feels much faster, but often it isn’t worth the cost.
These things save – seem to save – effort, which our primate brain is wired to. But laziness is a bitch. Lke cars, which when used a lot instead moving our body, only make our life shorter.
I have tried that with a small side project - a simple TUI app and parser in Rust - and I wasn’t convinced it is really faster. It spat out some 4,000 lines in about four afternoons, a bit of ratatui and so on. The cursor wasn’t visible. The fix was completely hallucinated, or BS, and suggested downloading and patching another lib. The parser was incorrect. It had over one hundred dependencies. I could fix it with two or three more afternoons time. Now, 4000 lines in a few days still sounds impressive, doesn’t it?
But then, I wanted to know it, threw the generated code away, and wrote it again from scratch. I got there with half the code and had it working. In the same time. With a working cursor and a better parser.
I think the speed perception is like when you are using public transport or a commuter train vs a bicycle. The motorized vehicle always feels faster. But at distances like ten miles / 15 kilometers, it isn’t. A car still feels much faster, but often it isn’t worth the cost.
These things save – seem to save – effort, which our primate brain is wired to. But laziness is a bitch. Lke cars, which when used a lot instead moving our body, only make our life shorter.