Fortunately fictional creatures don’t have to worry about pesky things like laws of physics.
There’s a related scene in the 2008 “The Incredible Hulk” where Banner transforms into Hulk while strapped to a table and mid-transformation, the table collapses under him. Not because the Hulk crushes it by flailing a refrigerator-sized forearm against it or anything. Just by outweighing the weight capacity of the table. I’ve thought about that scene more than is healthy since 2008. I don’t even remember the plot of the movie. Just that scene.
Does his body make inhaled air into muscle? If that was the case, I’d expect it would be like a wind tunnel in his immediate vicinity during the transformation. Does Bruce Banner hold some kind of portal to the elemental plane of muscle inside him from which his muscle comes? What if… and stay with me here… Banner doesn’t grow? What if some effect of his biology shrinks everything around him and makes it extra fragile?
I refuse to participate with anything regarding Antman. In the first movie, it is explained to Paul Rudd that when shrunken, he retains all the same mass as he did as a fully sized man and then falls through several floors of his apartment, apparently because roughly 200 lbs was focused to the size of a dime. Later on in the same movie, he’s standing on someone’s shoulder without them noticing and then standing on the tip of a goon’s outstretched gun. Not to mention the tank that the doctor keeps on his keychain. And don’t get me started on when he gets big.
Do these things keep their original mass or not?! At least ATTEMPT to make a halfassed explanation for it all!
Hulk’s power has always come from “gamma radiation”, but at some point - within the marvel universe - gamma radiation was discovered to originate via “green doors” which are inter dimensional portals from the ultimate evil (the one below all) in the cosmology. I’d say “hell” and “Satan”, but but those exist as separate concepts and are significantly less powerful than TOBA.
So the extra mass comes from evil portals to hell.
Honestly out of my ass. Matter is energy and the hulk is supposed to be this nuclear kinda creature. So maybe some kind of atomic reaction releases energy that reconstitutes into mass??
Ok, now I have to figure out how much energy that would take.
e = m * c^2, right? So, one pound (🇺🇸🙁) is 0.45 kg. The speed of light is around 300,000,000 meters per second. Multiplying kilograms by meters squared per second squared should give us joules. So 0.45 * 3e8 = 4.05e16. Roughly 40.5 quadrillion joules. That’s how much energy you would get if you converted 100% of a pound of mass into energy.
I googled a little bit and found an article that says he weighs between 1,040 and 1,400 lbs. So, we’ll assume he gains 1,000 lbs when he transforms just to keep the numbers round. That comes to 40.5 quintillion (4.05e19) joules.
40.5 quintillion divided by 209.2 quadrillion is about 193.6. So roughly speaking, the amount of energy that would have to be converted into mass in order to gain 1,000 lbs would be about 194 times as much energy as the output of the largest nuke ever made. Which is a lot closer than I thought it would be going into this.
The only issue with that theory, though, is that… that energy has to be stored somewhere inside him, right? (Or in a pocket dimension or something.) But energy has weight. Like, when you recharge your phone, your phone gains a very very tiny amount of mass. Storing 1,000 lbs of energy within his body would make him weigh over half a ton even when not Hulked out.
While I’m doing math, let’s figure out how much air would weigh 1,000 lbs. Wikipedia says that at 101.325 kPa and 15 °C, the density of air is 1.2250 kg/m^3. 1,000*0.45/1.2250 = 367.347. That is, 1,000 lbs times 0.45 kb/lb divided by 1.2250 kg/m^3 gives about 367 cubic meters. The cube root of that is about 7.162 meters. So a cube about 7.162 meters, which is about 23 feet, on a side. That doesn’t seem quite “wind tunnel” levels of sucking, especially since it takes a couple of seconds for him to transform.
Anyway, all the above depends of course on whether I did my math right. It’s late and I should be in bed, so that’s questionable at best.
Edit: Something that just occurred to me. If the most powerful nuke ever detonated produced 209.2 quadrillion joules, and a pound worth of energy is 40.5 quadrillion joules, that means that the most powerful nuke ever made converted fully five pounds of mass into energy in the process of exploding. As in, if you could collect all the pieces of the bomb together after it exploded and weigh it, you’d find it weighed 5lb less than it did before it was detonated. That’s… super fascinating to me.
Fortunately fictional creatures don’t have to worry about pesky things like laws of physics.
There’s a related scene in the 2008 “The Incredible Hulk” where Banner transforms into Hulk while strapped to a table and mid-transformation, the table collapses under him. Not because the Hulk crushes it by flailing a refrigerator-sized forearm against it or anything. Just by outweighing the weight capacity of the table. I’ve thought about that scene more than is healthy since 2008. I don’t even remember the plot of the movie. Just that scene.
Does his body make inhaled air into muscle? If that was the case, I’d expect it would be like a wind tunnel in his immediate vicinity during the transformation. Does Bruce Banner hold some kind of portal to the elemental plane of muscle inside him from which his muscle comes? What if… and stay with me here… Banner doesn’t grow? What if some effect of his biology shrinks everything around him and makes it extra fragile?
I refuse to participate with anything regarding Antman. In the first movie, it is explained to Paul Rudd that when shrunken, he retains all the same mass as he did as a fully sized man and then falls through several floors of his apartment, apparently because roughly 200 lbs was focused to the size of a dime. Later on in the same movie, he’s standing on someone’s shoulder without them noticing and then standing on the tip of a goon’s outstretched gun. Not to mention the tank that the doctor keeps on his keychain. And don’t get me started on when he gets big.
Do these things keep their original mass or not?! At least ATTEMPT to make a halfassed explanation for it all!
Hulk’s power has always come from “gamma radiation”, but at some point - within the marvel universe - gamma radiation was discovered to originate via “green doors” which are inter dimensional portals from the ultimate evil (the one below all) in the cosmology. I’d say “hell” and “Satan”, but but those exist as separate concepts and are significantly less powerful than TOBA.
So the extra mass comes from evil portals to hell.
Honestly out of my ass. Matter is energy and the hulk is supposed to be this nuclear kinda creature. So maybe some kind of atomic reaction releases energy that reconstitutes into mass??
I have no idea
Ok, now I have to figure out how much energy that would take.
e = m * c^2, right? So, one pound (🇺🇸🙁) is 0.45 kg. The speed of light is around 300,000,000 meters per second. Multiplying kilograms by meters squared per second squared should give us joules. So0.45 * 3e8 = 4.05e16. Roughly 40.5 quadrillion joules. That’s how much energy you would get if you converted 100% of a pound of mass into energy.I googled a little bit and found an article that says he weighs between 1,040 and 1,400 lbs. So, we’ll assume he gains 1,000 lbs when he transforms just to keep the numbers round. That comes to 40.5 quintillion (
4.05e19) joules.The most powerful nuclear weapen ever made was 50 megatons of TNT. A random website says 1 megaton of TNT is 4.184e15 joules. So the most powerful nuke ever made would be
50 * 4.184e15 = 2.092e17joules. (209.2 quadrillion joules.)40.5 quintillion divided by 209.2 quadrillion is about 193.6. So roughly speaking, the amount of energy that would have to be converted into mass in order to gain 1,000 lbs would be about 194 times as much energy as the output of the largest nuke ever made. Which is a lot closer than I thought it would be going into this.
The only issue with that theory, though, is that… that energy has to be stored somewhere inside him, right? (Or in a pocket dimension or something.) But energy has weight. Like, when you recharge your phone, your phone gains a very very tiny amount of mass. Storing 1,000 lbs of energy within his body would make him weigh over half a ton even when not Hulked out.
While I’m doing math, let’s figure out how much air would weigh 1,000 lbs. Wikipedia says that at 101.325 kPa and 15 °C, the density of air is
1.2250 kg/m^3.1,000*0.45/1.2250 = 367.347. That is, 1,000 lbs times 0.45 kb/lb divided by1.2250 kg/m^3gives about 367 cubic meters. The cube root of that is about 7.162 meters. So a cube about 7.162 meters, which is about 23 feet, on a side. That doesn’t seem quite “wind tunnel” levels of sucking, especially since it takes a couple of seconds for him to transform.Anyway, all the above depends of course on whether I did my math right. It’s late and I should be in bed, so that’s questionable at best.
Edit: Something that just occurred to me. If the most powerful nuke ever detonated produced 209.2 quadrillion joules, and a pound worth of energy is 40.5 quadrillion joules, that means that the most powerful nuke ever made converted fully five pounds of mass into energy in the process of exploding. As in, if you could collect all the pieces of the bomb together after it exploded and weigh it, you’d find it weighed 5lb less than it did before it was detonated. That’s… super fascinating to me.