Not sure why they’d down vote you; you’re mostly right about the inconsistency or vagueness. Very specific, personal stories tend to be true simply because most people aren’t terribly creative and what little details they might add might get lost in the bs.
Though it cuts both ways… wrong answers also include people who think an answer is a lie when it’s true. Turns out people also misremember and are vague about real life all the time, so it looks like a lie. So while a lie may have inconsistency, it can also just be someone being bad at describing something.
Yeah I guess it’s just mostly up to intuition. Not bulletproof by any means. But you can do stuff like ask for proof if it’s a stranger, or use your prior knowledge about the person if you’re familiar. It’s kind of like trying to tell if an image is A.I. generated nowadays
Ah, haha. And yeah, they never did say anything about reasoning skills and such, but that’s probably harder to study in a simple lab experiment. You’d think professions and training would have some effect though, but then again in the experiments they aren’t doing follow-up questions or using familiar people. It certainly gets more complex when you can investigate farther.
Not sure why they’d down vote you; you’re mostly right about the inconsistency or vagueness. Very specific, personal stories tend to be true simply because most people aren’t terribly creative and what little details they might add might get lost in the bs.
Though it cuts both ways… wrong answers also include people who think an answer is a lie when it’s true. Turns out people also misremember and are vague about real life all the time, so it looks like a lie. So while a lie may have inconsistency, it can also just be someone being bad at describing something.
I remove my own upvotes lol
Yeah I guess it’s just mostly up to intuition. Not bulletproof by any means. But you can do stuff like ask for proof if it’s a stranger, or use your prior knowledge about the person if you’re familiar. It’s kind of like trying to tell if an image is A.I. generated nowadays
Ah, haha. And yeah, they never did say anything about reasoning skills and such, but that’s probably harder to study in a simple lab experiment. You’d think professions and training would have some effect though, but then again in the experiments they aren’t doing follow-up questions or using familiar people. It certainly gets more complex when you can investigate farther.