Not sure what you mean. Could you point out a modern indigenous hunter-gatherer society that exists solely because of large-scale agriculture? We existed in one form or another for 4-8 million years as hunter gatherers and only started doing agriculture roughly 12,000 years ago…
Also “bullshit” is a bit rude, but maybe your culture is more crass than mine.
Not sure what you mean. Could you point out a modern indigenous hunter-gatherer society that exists solely because of large-scale agriculture?
Of course not, because that was never what I was talking about in the first place. You know, those are the small EXCEPTIONS to what I’m talking about, and god-bless’em, for sure. <3
We existed in one form or another for 4-8 million years as hunter gatherers and only started doing agriculture roughly 12,000 years ago…
If that’s not what you’re talking about, maybe you should clarify what you ARE talking about instead of what you aren’t since they’ve obviously misunderstood your meaning.
Okay, this may seem like a tangential lecture, but bear with me. In any case where someone is saying/writing something to someone else, there are two barriers to understanding; the writer’s ability to effectively put their thoughts into words and the reader’s ability to derive meaning from those words. The writer is limited by their ability to understand the context in which the reader will read their words and the reader is limited by the words they have to read.
You say that you are, of course, speaking about homo sapiens, but the only other time you used that word was the title of the book you’re talking about. Maybe the book talks about sapiens versus homo erectus or other near-human species (I haven’t read it), but the actual content of the words you had originally written focused exclusively on the agricultural society built after that “contest.” Because of that in my mind, and I presume the mind of trojanbark, every comment in this thread has been within the context of homo sapiens, so trojanbark was referring to societies of homo sapiens that still practice hunter-gathering to this day. Perhaps they could have given an example, such as the Inuit people, but I believe they were not referring to extinct near-human species because they had not been given the context that you have to be thinking in those terms.
If you care about being understood, I encourage you to take an extra moment when writing to consider what words will give the person you are writing to the context to understand your meaning, and if it sounds like someone is speaking a foreign language ask for more context to potentially understand better. Questions of meaning come before questions of truth.
Of course not, because that was never what I was talking about in the first place. You know, those are the small EXCEPTIONS to what I’m talking about, and god-bless’em, for sure. <3
Now I am even more confused. My original line and your response was this:
Many societies chose not to go down that path…
Bullshit. They got there via the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.
When I said “many societies,” I was referring to the indigenous hunter-gatherer societies that chose to remain as indigenous hunter-gatherer societies, and you stated, “Bullshit. They got there via the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.” I am pointing out that this does not make sense; hunter gatherers did not become hunter gatherers via “the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.” I am not a native English speaker, but it seems like maybe you were confused about what I was writing.
This is correct. However, we split off from the common ancestor with other apes roughly 4-8 million years ago; this is that to which I was referring. Many of us in the world do not consider our species as humans to have simply started with the genus homo, but to go back much further. In our culture, we really view the world as one continuous organism without distinction between its parts.
Sorry, but what were you hoping for as an adult, exactly? A babying upon the facts, is it?
Not sure what “babying upon the facts” means (again, I am not a native English speaker). I was simply hoping to have a fruitful conversation. I have been fortunate enough in my life to have many good conversations with people; even when we do not always agree upon the premises or arguments, we do treat each other with respect. Perhaps your culture is not the same as our culture, or perhaps you are experiencing some anger issues which you are projecting into this conversation. I hope you are able to feel better though, you do seem like a passionate person.
Not sure what you mean. Could you point out a modern indigenous hunter-gatherer society that exists solely because of large-scale agriculture? We existed in one form or another for 4-8 million years as hunter gatherers and only started doing agriculture roughly 12,000 years ago…
Also “bullshit” is a bit rude, but maybe your culture is more crass than mine.
Of course not, because that was never what I was talking about in the first place. You know, those are the small EXCEPTIONS to what I’m talking about, and god-bless’em, for sure. <3
We existed as “Homo” for ~2.5Myrs, so maybe check yourself on that, mate:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo
Sorry, but what were you hoping for as an adult, exactly? A babying upon the facts, is it?
If that’s not what you’re talking about, maybe you should clarify what you ARE talking about instead of what you aren’t since they’ve obviously misunderstood your meaning.
What part was confusing?
Presumably who the “they” are in “They got there via the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.”
we sapiens, of course
we’d already wiped out all other humans (there were ~six of us) going back ~50Kyrs
“of course”
Okay, this may seem like a tangential lecture, but bear with me. In any case where someone is saying/writing something to someone else, there are two barriers to understanding; the writer’s ability to effectively put their thoughts into words and the reader’s ability to derive meaning from those words. The writer is limited by their ability to understand the context in which the reader will read their words and the reader is limited by the words they have to read.
You say that you are, of course, speaking about homo sapiens, but the only other time you used that word was the title of the book you’re talking about. Maybe the book talks about sapiens versus homo erectus or other near-human species (I haven’t read it), but the actual content of the words you had originally written focused exclusively on the agricultural society built after that “contest.” Because of that in my mind, and I presume the mind of trojanbark, every comment in this thread has been within the context of homo sapiens, so trojanbark was referring to societies of homo sapiens that still practice hunter-gathering to this day. Perhaps they could have given an example, such as the Inuit people, but I believe they were not referring to extinct near-human species because they had not been given the context that you have to be thinking in those terms.
If you care about being understood, I encourage you to take an extra moment when writing to consider what words will give the person you are writing to the context to understand your meaning, and if it sounds like someone is speaking a foreign language ask for more context to potentially understand better. Questions of meaning come before questions of truth.
Padre, that was a good attempt, yet completely wasted, lol. I like how you started off though, which I thought was quite excellent and relatable.
If only you’d applied that rigorous spirit of examination towards your wishful belief system you tried to push on me, right there…
Ah… but then… okay, I get it.
Sorry.
Now I am even more confused. My original line and your response was this:
When I said “many societies,” I was referring to the indigenous hunter-gatherer societies that chose to remain as indigenous hunter-gatherer societies, and you stated, “Bullshit. They got there via the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.” I am pointing out that this does not make sense; hunter gatherers did not become hunter gatherers via “the fruits of large-scale agriculture, every single time.” I am not a native English speaker, but it seems like maybe you were confused about what I was writing.
This is correct. However, we split off from the common ancestor with other apes roughly 4-8 million years ago; this is that to which I was referring. Many of us in the world do not consider our species as humans to have simply started with the genus homo, but to go back much further. In our culture, we really view the world as one continuous organism without distinction between its parts.
Not sure what “babying upon the facts” means (again, I am not a native English speaker). I was simply hoping to have a fruitful conversation. I have been fortunate enough in my life to have many good conversations with people; even when we do not always agree upon the premises or arguments, we do treat each other with respect. Perhaps your culture is not the same as our culture, or perhaps you are experiencing some anger issues which you are projecting into this conversation. I hope you are able to feel better though, you do seem like a passionate person.
Dans ce cas, je vous tire mon chapeau. J’essaie toujours de commencer les choses de la meilleure manière possible.
Cela dit, j’essaie également de m’en tenir, dans la mesure du possible, aux faits avérés et à la réalité.
Vous êtes bien sûr libre d’interpréter cela comme bon vous semble.