I’m asking this because there is a scifi book I’m reading, and in the book there’s a scene where someone is communicating with a person in a spacecraft moving at lightspeed. I know their ability to communicate would probably not be possible, but let’s just put that aside for a second. Hypothetically, if you could communicate with someone moving lightspeed, would the time dilation make it so that they would appear to be moving and speaking very slowly relative to you?

  • musicalphysics@discuss.online
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    21 hours ago

    Well, parts of interstellar are accurate. :) That being said, time dilation due to gravity is real. Go someplace heavy for awhile and then leave and you will travel far into the future. The spaceship-observer example is special relativity. The gravity thing is general relativity. I’m not sure I have a non math explanation here so, simply put, time dilation due to gravity is different.

    You can get a similar outcome by going somewhere real fast, then turning around, and going real fast again back towards the start. In the rocket frame that may take, say 10 years, but more years will have passed by on Earth.

    You may think this breaks the symmetry I brought up earlier, and it does, but that symmetry breaking occurs when the rocket accelerates a whole bunch turning around and heading back home. On the outbound journey though the rocket will think the earth clock is slow, and vice versa. Similarly, on the return journey the same thing occurs. During the acceleration phase though things gets real weird. Or weirder I should say.

    • a_gee_dizzle@lemmy.caOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      6 hours ago

      Well, parts of interstellar are accurate. :)

      Wait, you’re telling me it’s not scientifically accurate to say that love is the one thing we’re capable of perceiving that transcends the dimensions of time and space? /s

      You may think this breaks the symmetry I brought up earlier, and it does, but that symmetry breaking occurs when the rocket accelerates a whole bunch turning around and heading back home.

      Ah, okay that answers my question then. It’s the acceleration and deceleration that changes things. Thanks for bearing with me so far and answering all my questions!