in different social networks I often see a table of fediverse alternatives to centralized social networks like twitter = mastodon and so on, but I noticed that the alternative to reddit is piefed and not lemmy, can someone explain what kind of fediverse project this is, and is it different from lemmy?🤔
I’d disagree on that:
Slashdot’s moderation & metamoderation system was better than any system without metamoderation,
& reddit’s idiotic you-can-post-or-comment-to-collect-karma-and-delete-your-post-or-comment-keeping-your-karma … distortion … isn’t something that’s intrinsic to karma-systems: they made it intrinsic to their system by choice, which is different.
I’d have it so that if someone tries karma-farming, the instant they delete the posts/comments, all the karma from those disappears, right then.
( actually, I’d have it so that nothing can be deleted, & revisions are limited to 8 or 16 per post/comment: accountability requires that disappearing-of-history not be permitted )
Also, Slashdot had multiple, not only up/down, kinds of votes…
That’s required, too…
Being unable to simultaneously vote that something is wrong & that it needs more eyes on it… is obstruction.
_ /\ _
It’s not like you can detect “if someone tries karma farming”. If the platform displays a measure of engagement with content that a user posts, users will be driven to post things that get them points. Then if the platform uses said metric to rank content, that unavoidably leads to a setup where users look at content posted for the purpose of getting points. Btw lemmy.world is also not free from this, people repost engagement bait stupid shit from Reddit to asklemmy all the time, and those get many upvotes and comments. But at least the users that post these don’t get any meta-post outcomes.