Unfortunately that’s just how psychiatry is. You can get a metabolic test done that tells what meds your liver metabolizes better, but ultimately it’s throwing darts and hoping something sticks.
Hot tip, if any of your family members have similar mental heath conditions ask them what meds they’re on. Worked out very well for my partner after trying several drugs she asked what her dad was on and tried that. It worked great
You can just have this tested at most psychiatrists. Genesight is one version, there are a few. If your insurance covers it you basically just have to spit in a cup. If you don’t the cost is capped at $330 for genesight which is a lot. Their argument is that in that case it can still be worthwhile to avoid paying for meds that aren’t a good fit. That said this is a bit absurd as most first line psych meds are dirt cheap. Like fluoxetine is like $25 and you can often get it down to 0 with those prescription card things. If they start you on pristiq or fetzima then it’s way more, hundreds per month, but if your psychiatrist is starting you with those they’ve been corrupted by a pharmaceutical rep
$330 for a genetic sequencing is fucking robbery. The cost to sequence is under $100, a major breakthrough in genetic testing dropped the cost to $80 per sequence. An extremely detailed research-grade sequencing is around $200. The U of Minnesota charges $250 for everything from sequencing to analysis for external screenings
The worst case scenario is that it’s mostly placebo, and when it does work, it’s just natural recovery; and, further, that the psychiatrists’ prescription pattern is entirely based on “what’s worked” in their personal history as prescriber which will, of course, be random.
Anyway, long term studies on the effects of most psychotropic drugs indicate that they are much more likely to induce dependence than to actually “cure” you.
The worst case scenario is that it’s mostly placebo, and when it does work, it’s just natural recovery
I believed that for 30 years until I tried zoloft and experienced a sensation somewhat similar to that of psilocybin, which has also been linked to treating depression, and then I went “ohhh…” and stayed on it until the side effects wore off and yeah. It’s not just placebo. I was wrong. I’m sorry to everyone on the internet I misled.
Sertraline is unlikely to reduce depressive symptoms within 6 weeks in primary care but we observed improvements in anxiety, quality of life, and self-rated mental health, which are likely to be clinically important. Our findings support the prescription of SSRI antidepressants in a wider group of participants than previously thought, including those with mild to moderate symptoms who do not meet diagnostic criteria for depression or generalised anxiety disorder.
That’s actually pretty much spot on how it worked for me. My depression was cause of things in my life, and it didn’t do much for that, but it did wonders for my anxiety, which made it easier for me to ask for help and fix my life. I used to be afraid of going into stores. I used to be afraid of pain, due to pain disorders I have. I couldn’t have caffeine, or even chocolate, because even a little bit of stimulant made me too jittery and feel awful. I don’t have so much fear anymore. I can eat chocolate again!
Most of those meds aren’t intended to cure you. You’re supposed to take them in conjunction with therapy to develop healthy ways of managing the disorder.
Yes, much like diabetes someone with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia is going to be taking the medication their whole life. And much like diabetes, working with a medical professional will help them to identify lifestyle changes and coping strategies that allow them to eventually self-regulate their medical concerns, and they will only need occasional professional involvement.
Maybe in some shitty countries, but over here we ain’t prescribing shit without a decent evidence base because the medical regulator is actually competent.
The studies for efficacy in the US are mostly short-term. Psychiatric outcomes in “shitty countries” uninfected with pro-medicine psychiatry are actually better.
Oh my gosh, you really didn’t know the definition! That’s why you don’t have any refutation or argument, and instead you’re having to do this tired “I meant to do that” routine wherein you desperately try to imply there’s somehow more to the question that you’re aware of but we as a group somehow missed, and something that’s so obvious you don’t even need to explain it!
That’s what I’m doing? I had no idea. I thought I was giving you guys the benefit of the doubt and reading your cited definition completely and finding that you picked and chose quotes that supported your claim. But hey why explain myself when you’ll reply with what I really meant…
… Dude. Dude. It’s the literal first sentence of the wikipedia page. It couldn’t be less cherrypicked without my going out and ducktaping it into a cherry tree. Again, you’re not providing anything of substance to disprove the argument - you’re just desperate, and you’re once again resorting to implying that my argument is bad to try and save some face. You’re even trying to indicate it would be unreasonable to expect you to try and provide an argument at all, another transparent attempt to deflect the fact your utter lack of an argument (and nonexistent familiarity with the topic) is the whole point.
There’s really good reasons for that, chief among them that BOLD FMRI is basically useless in a clinical setting. “Dowsing for brain activity” was how one PI described it to me.
Not only do we leave out women, 50% of the species. Most modern medical research is done with the thought that treatment makes more money than cures. Just because us poors don’t see each other as cattle; Doesn’t mean the powers at be see us as people.
So sure. Show of your fancy shmancy chemistry. Shower me with the finest 225mg of Venlafaxine + 150mg Lamotrigine your alchemists can concoct! Depression is just keeps going up no matter what these poor bastards prescribe.
The reality of situation actively spirals downward as we continue this farce.
But hey at least I feel better. 😬 I can like, play video games again. Or make inappropriate jokes about healthcare CEOs at the doctors office! I was prescribed with 5mg of Ozlansapine for that one. Oof.
I didn’t say neurochemistry wasn’t a thing I said that proof of efficacy is based on anecdotal evidence. That is factually correct. I assume you’re one of the roughly 50% that takes an antidepressant and feels better which means you’ll defend the industry even though the other 50% sees no relief.
You know your argument is good when you’re stooping to trying to discredit someone by accusing them of… er… “having medication work for them”
proof of efficacy is based on anecdotal evidence
This is a bad take on so many different levels. Besides the classic “the plural of anecdote is data”, it belies a complete lack of even passing familiarity with how psychopharmacology, psychology and neurochemistry research works.
Oh so you’re not medicated and just have an interest in the psychopharmaceutical industry as a hobby… My bad.
Look, I’m not going to argue with you. I’m very familiar with the process, but you strike me as the type that conveniently omits issues that don’t support your point.
And now you’re trying to discredit my argument because you suppose I’m… not medicated? Man, just not many options left are there.
I’m very familiar with the process
If this were true, it wouldn’t be a very flattering thing to admit; it would mean you have willfully chosen to misrepresent fundamental aspects of multiple extremely important fields, instead of doing it out of simple ignorance. But please rest assured I don’t think that’s the case.
Aaaanyways not that I don’t enjoy taking my rhetorical scattergun on a recreational delve through the deepity depths of a fish-reeking barrel, but this is sorta straying from the topic into petty squabbling. Ta!
Having taken them in the past and watched others taking them; yeah they’re basically chalk capsules. Nothing wrong with chalk, they’re actually a really great way to get someone to start effective treatments and improve their lives.
There’s a reason why you always have to make other lifestyle changes and do therapy alongside the medication in order for it to “work”. And then, after all the lifestyle changes - oh would you look at that - you don’t even need the medication anymore because your depression is cured! Best part is, there isn’t even any withdrawals for some reason! Don’t think about it! But the downside I’ve also seen people take a handful of medications, change nothing, and then get even more depressed because the magic pill isn’t working.
People make fun of organised religion, then pay tithe and pray to the antidepressant and antianxiety God every morning. Go figure.
I thought I was going insane and worried it was permanent when I quit Zoloft cold turkey. I had horrifying flashing images in my minds eye and brain zaps for weeks.
You’re using your singular personal anecdotal experience to color your opinion of mental disorder pharmaceuticals as a whole. Basically, you don’t have enough information to support your conclusions.
For example, I have personal anecdotal experience that directly refutes yours regarding withdrawal symptoms. There is also clinical evidence that refutes your claims on withdrawal symptoms. It seems you haven’t considered those pieces of information, or else you favor your anecdotal evidence over all else, which is a pretty ignorant way to form an opinion and make claims based on it.
Keep in mind, being called ignorant isn’t necessarily an insult, even though it’s frequently used that way, it just means you’re missing or failing to consider some important pieces of information.
I suppose our opposing personal anecdotal experiences cancel each other out then 🤔. Also, it’s kind of ironic to be ignorant of ignorant’s status as an insult with that usage lol
b : resulting from or showing lack of knowledge or intelligence
There are several meanings of ignorant, all of which are concerned with a lack of knowledge in some sense; some of these are more insulting than others, and care should be exercised before applying this word to people who you do not wish to offend. Saying “They were ignorant of most of the laws of physics” means that the people in question did not have a specific body of learning. Saying “You are an ignorant person” is possibly describing someone as primitive, crude, or uncivilized.
And yes, I tend to trust my eyes, ears, and personal experiences over what people tell me; doing otherwise seems silly to me. Would you really ignore your entire personal lived experience, with all the proven first hand evidence, and blindly trust a stranger? Even a doctor or researcher? No. I’ve had doctors tell me incorrect information to my face with absolute conviction, and contradict each other; nobody is infallible.
The important part is, if I encounter new information, I’ll update my opinion. In this case, I’ll keep in mind that some people say they get withdrawals from antidepressants.
I believe antidepressants work because people think they work. Placebo is an amazing and miraculous effect. However, to me, taking antidepressants to solve depression is like drinking coffee to solve fatigue. Even if it does work, eventually you adapt, and it just becomes your “new normal”; without solving the underlying cause.
Now you’re actually worse off: depressed, addicted to drugs, and suffering the financial hardship of the medical and medication process. It’s a band-aid temporary fix, but people try to metaphorically stitch their entire arm back on using only band-aids. It’s a soul level problem being treated with neurochemicals.
Also, I never said anything about other mental health pharmaceuticals. We’re specifically talking about antidepressants here.
And yes, I tend to trust my eyes, ears, and personal experiences over what people tell me; doing otherwise seems silly to me.
K, that’s fine, to a point. If you do that to the exclusion of everyone else’s experiences, you’re doing yourself a disservice.
Would you really ignore your entire personal lived experience, with all the proven first hand evidence, and blindly trust a stranger? Even a doctor or researcher? No.
I wouldn’t ignore my personal lived experience, but I certainly wouldn’t use that discrepancy to ignore doctors and researchers. If a doctor or researcher told me something that differed from my lived experience, I’d do some research myself to figure out why the difference is happening, or to find out if my reasoning about my personal experience is flawed. I recognize the possibility of the researcher or doctor being wrong (and I recognize the much more likely possibility of myself being wrong in a field I have no expertise in), and in case of a personal doctor giving me conflicting information, I’d reach out directly for clarification. Trust but verify.
The important part is, if I encounter new information, I’ll update my opinion. In this case, I’ll keep in mind that some people say they get withdrawals from antidepressants.
That’s fair. If you actively seek new information and challenge your own beliefs, that’s great. The problem comes if you stubbornly refuse to seek new information or challenge your beliefs because you mistrust science or something, and I get the feeling that you fall into that camp, because you say things like:
I believe antidepressants work because people think they work.
And you didn’t realize antidepressants have both anecdotal and clinically proven withdrawal symptoms until a random guy on the internet told you.
However, to me, taking antidepressants to solve depression is like drinking coffee to solve fatigue.
That example is explicitly not placebo. Caffeine does absolutely do something physiologically in your brain - it blocks your adenosine receptors, effectively temporarily turning off the “go to sleep” signals in your brain.
Antidepressants are similar, in that they also typically bind to receptors in the brain. In the case of SSRIs, they typically bind to seratonin transporter molecules, which means more seratonin is available to do the things seratonin does, like helping stabilize your mood and emotions.
I won’t refute that you can develop resistance to antidepressants/SSRIs, because you absolutely can. But you can also develop resistance to insulin. You wouldn’t use that reasoning to tell a diabetic person that their insulin is just a placebo though, instead of life saving and necessary medication, right?
it just becomes your “new normal”; without solving the underlying cause.
In my personal experience, and in most of the scientific literature I’ve read on the topic, the medical standard for treating moderate to severe cases of depression is to combine antidepressants with some other form of therapy, like CBT, DBT, physical therapy, diet changes, etc. So yeah, antidepressants alone probably can’t fix the whole problem in moderate/severe cases. But they absolutely do address the physiological problems in a very real way. Calling it a band-aid temporary fix and implying that it’s the only thing doctors use to treat depression does absolutely show that you’re “lacking knowledge or education” in this area, which absolutely fits that first definition of “ignorant”.
There’s no need to talk down to me like that, or make presumptions about me as a person, or my history. I’m happy to discuss this, but only with civility. From the other side of the screen, you’re the one coming across as closed-minded and dismissive.
Your original post is grossly negligent which compelled me to respond and I choose to believe you’re ignorant not malicious. Your subsequent reply leads me to believe you’re angry and seeking out quarrels.
Personal experiences are anecdotal. People are absurdly ignorant of their own existence. It’s inseparable from the human condition. I don’t know how I’m alive; I can’t describe in detail all the biological processes that occur in my body. People are also ignorant of the things that influence them and that’s again part of being human which is why broadcasting your personal anecdote as a universal truth is foolish. You’re ridiculing doctors and scientists out of a hate.
People are different and respond differently to the same drug. That shouldn’t raise anyone’s skepticism as our variety is on display at any gathering of people. It would be a grave mistake to assume the differences stop at the visible external organs. Disease is natural and everywhere too and as a statement that should not raise any skepticism. It follows logically then that as some are born visibly deformed at birth others’ deformities only become apparent as the individual matures or are entirely invisible to the observer and are only deduced by diseased-behaviour.
Depression is complex in both origin and in classification. A patient does not necessarily know what they’re suffering from or that they’re even diseased–again it’s part of being human and we are naturally blind in regards to our internal mechanisms.
Disregarding the fact that your personal experience is anecdotal nothing you’ve written refutes the body of scientific literature on depression! You might have been prescribed a drug that your body could not use in which case it will do as much for you as a chalk-capsule would.
There are blood tests you can pay for that will give you an indication as to which drugs are likely to have the intended therapeutic response and which will not. These aren’t definitive though. They’re not subsidised by Medicare either so some doctors will simply not mention them and you will get a random antidepressant that might do absolutely nothing for you.
That’s the other thing about depression: there’s no good treatment for it. The drugs are lousy. The disease could be a result of a myriad of different things. An individual with undiagnosed ADHD but is requesting aid for major depression? Treat the ADHD and the depression goes away.
Things aren’t as simple as you angrily and ignorantly claim them to be. A change in diet and an increase in exercise will do as much good as an antidepressant for some people. That’s a truth that sits alongside the fact that diet, exercise and antidepressants all have no positive effect on mood for some individuals. An antidepressant could also be a lifesaver for another. Life’s complicated and that complication doesn’t cease at our skin.
Hang on, I’m confused. I thought you were the other person replying under a different account? You can go check out that thread if you want I guess.
Anyway. I’m not angry or hateful, mate, that’s 100% projection. You’re making a lot of assumptions about me based on a personal opinion. Also, as mentioned in other thread, this was simply my opinion, not a PHD thesis I’m obligated to defend.
If I ignore all the personal attacks and insults in this thread, I actually agree with you. It makes sense to me that maybe just all the people in my circle (myself included) just got ones we couldn’t process. Doctors didn’t tell us anything about this, I didn’t even know that was a thing; and they didn’t offer any additional treatment other than throwing pills at us.
But the way you wrote this… honestly my initial reaction was to want to report/block you, and not read it. I’m glad I did, because there’s actually useful information in there, but c’mon, you can do better.
Just FYI; if you ever feel like other people are “hostile and argumentative” online, I would actually suggest reflecting on your own communication style. Cold starting out with an insult, then sprinkling in needless attacks in your explanation, is honestly just troll behaviour. Nothing in my original comment deserved this kind of abuse.
Unfortunately that’s just how psychiatry is. You can get a metabolic test done that tells what meds your liver metabolizes better, but ultimately it’s throwing darts and hoping something sticks.
Hot tip, if any of your family members have similar mental heath conditions ask them what meds they’re on. Worked out very well for my partner after trying several drugs she asked what her dad was on and tried that. It worked great
Makes sense genetically
LOL. I found out my aunt was on the same med after being on it for ten years.
It is one of those in the comic.
You can just have this tested at most psychiatrists. Genesight is one version, there are a few. If your insurance covers it you basically just have to spit in a cup. If you don’t the cost is capped at $330 for genesight which is a lot. Their argument is that in that case it can still be worthwhile to avoid paying for meds that aren’t a good fit. That said this is a bit absurd as most first line psych meds are dirt cheap. Like fluoxetine is like $25 and you can often get it down to 0 with those prescription card things. If they start you on pristiq or fetzima then it’s way more, hundreds per month, but if your psychiatrist is starting you with those they’ve been corrupted by a pharmaceutical rep
None of these tests have good privacy practices
$330 for a genetic sequencing is fucking robbery. The cost to sequence is under $100, a major breakthrough in genetic testing dropped the cost to $80 per sequence. An extremely detailed research-grade sequencing is around $200. The U of Minnesota charges $250 for everything from sequencing to analysis for external screenings
Amazing how the psychiatrist never mentioned this when none of the drugs were helping
That’s the best case scenario.
The worst case scenario is that it’s mostly placebo, and when it does work, it’s just natural recovery; and, further, that the psychiatrists’ prescription pattern is entirely based on “what’s worked” in their personal history as prescriber which will, of course, be random.
Anyway, long term studies on the effects of most psychotropic drugs indicate that they are much more likely to induce dependence than to actually “cure” you.
I believed that for 30 years until I tried zoloft and experienced a sensation somewhat similar to that of psilocybin, which has also been linked to treating depression, and then I went “ohhh…” and stayed on it until the side effects wore off and yeah. It’s not just placebo. I was wrong. I’m sorry to everyone on the internet I misled.
One of many studies concluding, “meh.”
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lanpsy/article/PIIS2215-0366(19)30366-9/fulltext
This… doesn’t seem very meh?
That’s actually pretty much spot on how it worked for me. My depression was cause of things in my life, and it didn’t do much for that, but it did wonders for my anxiety, which made it easier for me to ask for help and fix my life. I used to be afraid of going into stores. I used to be afraid of pain, due to pain disorders I have. I couldn’t have caffeine, or even chocolate, because even a little bit of stimulant made me too jittery and feel awful. I don’t have so much fear anymore. I can eat chocolate again!
Most of those meds aren’t intended to cure you. You’re supposed to take them in conjunction with therapy to develop healthy ways of managing the disorder.
That reminds me of that joke about the pill that cures thirst. You just take it along with a cup of water, and voilà, the thirst is gone
Medical treatment for bipolar and schizophrenia is considered lifelong.
For depression, yes, there is one strand of thought it that pairs it with talk therapy, but often people are on the drugs for years.
Yes, much like diabetes someone with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia is going to be taking the medication their whole life. And much like diabetes, working with a medical professional will help them to identify lifestyle changes and coping strategies that allow them to eventually self-regulate their medical concerns, and they will only need occasional professional involvement.
Maybe in some shitty countries, but over here we ain’t prescribing shit without a decent evidence base because the medical regulator is actually competent.
The studies for efficacy in the US are mostly short-term. Psychiatric outcomes in “shitty countries” uninfected with pro-medicine psychiatry are actually better.
You’re claiming the US doesn’t count as a shitty country when it comes to healthcare?
Not arguing much of anything vis-a-vis the US, but most of what gets approved here gets approved everywhere else.
I don’t know of any credible evidence that my country’s medical regulator has been captured by the pharmaceutical industry.
It’s an entire industry based on anecdotal evidence and we just go along with it.
You don’t know what anecdotal evidence is
Oh? Enlighten me.
Lol you snooty bandwagoners should really read more than just the bits that support your claim. Lol good grief…
Oh my gosh, you really didn’t know the definition! That’s why you don’t have any refutation or argument, and instead you’re having to do this tired “I meant to do that” routine wherein you desperately try to imply there’s somehow more to the question that you’re aware of but we as a group somehow missed, and something that’s so obvious you don’t even need to explain it!
That’s what I’m doing? I had no idea. I thought I was giving you guys the benefit of the doubt and reading your cited definition completely and finding that you picked and chose quotes that supported your claim. But hey why explain myself when you’ll reply with what I really meant…
… Dude. Dude. It’s the literal first sentence of the wikipedia page. It couldn’t be less cherrypicked without my going out and ducktaping it into a cherry tree. Again, you’re not providing anything of substance to disprove the argument - you’re just desperate, and you’re once again resorting to implying that my argument is bad to try and save some face. You’re even trying to indicate it would be unreasonable to expect you to try and provide an argument at all, another transparent attempt to deflect the fact your utter lack of an argument (and nonexistent familiarity with the topic) is the whole point.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neurochemistry
Active brain scanning with FMRI is still too rarely used in diagnosis and testing for brain related illness.
There’s really good reasons for that, chief among them that BOLD FMRI is basically useless in a clinical setting. “Dowsing for brain activity” was how one PI described it to me.
It is well know that modern researches is done with males as the defualt. Shit bro humans did not start testing tampons with blood until 2023
Not only do we leave out women, 50% of the species. Most modern medical research is done with the thought that treatment makes more money than cures. Just because us poors don’t see each other as cattle; Doesn’t mean the powers at be see us as people.
So sure. Show of your fancy shmancy chemistry. Shower me with the finest 225mg of Venlafaxine + 150mg Lamotrigine your alchemists can concoct! Depression is just keeps going up no matter what these poor bastards prescribe.
The reality of situation actively spirals downward as we continue this farce.
But hey at least I feel better. 😬 I can like, play video games again. Or make inappropriate jokes about healthcare CEOs at the doctors office! I was prescribed with 5mg of Ozlansapine for that one. Oof.
I mean I don’t think I disagree? But I admit I’m not sure what it has to do with best practice for data collection in medical studies.
I didn’t say neurochemistry wasn’t a thing I said that proof of efficacy is based on anecdotal evidence. That is factually correct. I assume you’re one of the roughly 50% that takes an antidepressant and feels better which means you’ll defend the industry even though the other 50% sees no relief.
You know your argument is good when you’re stooping to trying to discredit someone by accusing them of… er… “having medication work for them”
This is a bad take on so many different levels. Besides the classic “the plural of anecdote is data”, it belies a complete lack of even passing familiarity with how psychopharmacology, psychology and neurochemistry research works.
Oh so you’re not medicated and just have an interest in the psychopharmaceutical industry as a hobby… My bad.
Look, I’m not going to argue with you. I’m very familiar with the process, but you strike me as the type that conveniently omits issues that don’t support your point.
And now you’re trying to discredit my argument because you suppose I’m… not medicated? Man, just not many options left are there.
If this were true, it wouldn’t be a very flattering thing to admit; it would mean you have willfully chosen to misrepresent fundamental aspects of multiple extremely important fields, instead of doing it out of simple ignorance. But please rest assured I don’t think that’s the case.
Aaaanyways not that I don’t enjoy taking my rhetorical scattergun on a recreational delve through the deepity depths of a fish-reeking barrel, but this is sorta straying from the topic into petty squabbling. Ta!
Having taken them in the past and watched others taking them; yeah they’re basically chalk capsules. Nothing wrong with chalk, they’re actually a really great way to get someone to start effective treatments and improve their lives.
There’s a reason why you always have to make other lifestyle changes and do therapy alongside the medication in order for it to “work”. And then, after all the lifestyle changes - oh would you look at that - you don’t even need the medication anymore because your depression is cured! Best part is, there isn’t even any withdrawals for some reason! Don’t think about it! But the downside I’ve also seen people take a handful of medications, change nothing, and then get even more depressed because the magic pill isn’t working.
People make fun of organised religion, then pay tithe and pray to the antidepressant and antianxiety God every morning. Go figure.
Wdym no withdrawal symptoms? Suddenly stopping SSRIs has pretty severe symptoms
It didn’t for me or anybody I know. Maybe the doctor literally just gave us fake pills and everyone else got real pills lol who knows
I thought I was going insane and worried it was permanent when I quit Zoloft cold turkey. I had horrifying flashing images in my minds eye and brain zaps for weeks.
You’re boldly ignorant.
deleted by creator
I don’t understand how a personal experience can be ignorant. Are you calling me a liar?
You’re using your singular personal anecdotal experience to color your opinion of mental disorder pharmaceuticals as a whole. Basically, you don’t have enough information to support your conclusions.
For example, I have personal anecdotal experience that directly refutes yours regarding withdrawal symptoms. There is also clinical evidence that refutes your claims on withdrawal symptoms. It seems you haven’t considered those pieces of information, or else you favor your anecdotal evidence over all else, which is a pretty ignorant way to form an opinion and make claims based on it.
Keep in mind, being called ignorant isn’t necessarily an insult, even though it’s frequently used that way, it just means you’re missing or failing to consider some important pieces of information.
I suppose our opposing personal anecdotal experiences cancel each other out then 🤔. Also, it’s kind of ironic to be ignorant of ignorant’s status as an insult with that usage lol
Merriam Webster
And yes, I tend to trust my eyes, ears, and personal experiences over what people tell me; doing otherwise seems silly to me. Would you really ignore your entire personal lived experience, with all the proven first hand evidence, and blindly trust a stranger? Even a doctor or researcher? No. I’ve had doctors tell me incorrect information to my face with absolute conviction, and contradict each other; nobody is infallible.
The important part is, if I encounter new information, I’ll update my opinion. In this case, I’ll keep in mind that some people say they get withdrawals from antidepressants.
I believe antidepressants work because people think they work. Placebo is an amazing and miraculous effect. However, to me, taking antidepressants to solve depression is like drinking coffee to solve fatigue. Even if it does work, eventually you adapt, and it just becomes your “new normal”; without solving the underlying cause.
Now you’re actually worse off: depressed, addicted to drugs, and suffering the financial hardship of the medical and medication process. It’s a band-aid temporary fix, but people try to metaphorically stitch their entire arm back on using only band-aids. It’s a soul level problem being treated with neurochemicals.
Also, I never said anything about other mental health pharmaceuticals. We’re specifically talking about antidepressants here.
K, that’s fine, to a point. If you do that to the exclusion of everyone else’s experiences, you’re doing yourself a disservice.
I wouldn’t ignore my personal lived experience, but I certainly wouldn’t use that discrepancy to ignore doctors and researchers. If a doctor or researcher told me something that differed from my lived experience, I’d do some research myself to figure out why the difference is happening, or to find out if my reasoning about my personal experience is flawed. I recognize the possibility of the researcher or doctor being wrong (and I recognize the much more likely possibility of myself being wrong in a field I have no expertise in), and in case of a personal doctor giving me conflicting information, I’d reach out directly for clarification. Trust but verify.
That’s fair. If you actively seek new information and challenge your own beliefs, that’s great. The problem comes if you stubbornly refuse to seek new information or challenge your beliefs because you mistrust science or something, and I get the feeling that you fall into that camp, because you say things like:
And you didn’t realize antidepressants have both anecdotal and clinically proven withdrawal symptoms until a random guy on the internet told you.
That example is explicitly not placebo. Caffeine does absolutely do something physiologically in your brain - it blocks your adenosine receptors, effectively temporarily turning off the “go to sleep” signals in your brain.
Antidepressants are similar, in that they also typically bind to receptors in the brain. In the case of SSRIs, they typically bind to seratonin transporter molecules, which means more seratonin is available to do the things seratonin does, like helping stabilize your mood and emotions.
I won’t refute that you can develop resistance to antidepressants/SSRIs, because you absolutely can. But you can also develop resistance to insulin. You wouldn’t use that reasoning to tell a diabetic person that their insulin is just a placebo though, instead of life saving and necessary medication, right?
In my personal experience, and in most of the scientific literature I’ve read on the topic, the medical standard for treating moderate to severe cases of depression is to combine antidepressants with some other form of therapy, like CBT, DBT, physical therapy, diet changes, etc. So yeah, antidepressants alone probably can’t fix the whole problem in moderate/severe cases. But they absolutely do address the physiological problems in a very real way. Calling it a band-aid temporary fix and implying that it’s the only thing doctors use to treat depression does absolutely show that you’re “lacking knowledge or education” in this area, which absolutely fits that first definition of “ignorant”.
There’s no need to talk down to me like that, or make presumptions about me as a person, or my history. I’m happy to discuss this, but only with civility. From the other side of the screen, you’re the one coming across as closed-minded and dismissive.
Your original post is grossly negligent which compelled me to respond and I choose to believe you’re ignorant not malicious. Your subsequent reply leads me to believe you’re angry and seeking out quarrels.
Personal experiences are anecdotal. People are absurdly ignorant of their own existence. It’s inseparable from the human condition. I don’t know how I’m alive; I can’t describe in detail all the biological processes that occur in my body. People are also ignorant of the things that influence them and that’s again part of being human which is why broadcasting your personal anecdote as a universal truth is foolish. You’re ridiculing doctors and scientists out of a hate.
People are different and respond differently to the same drug. That shouldn’t raise anyone’s skepticism as our variety is on display at any gathering of people. It would be a grave mistake to assume the differences stop at the visible external organs. Disease is natural and everywhere too and as a statement that should not raise any skepticism. It follows logically then that as some are born visibly deformed at birth others’ deformities only become apparent as the individual matures or are entirely invisible to the observer and are only deduced by diseased-behaviour.
Depression is complex in both origin and in classification. A patient does not necessarily know what they’re suffering from or that they’re even diseased–again it’s part of being human and we are naturally blind in regards to our internal mechanisms.
Disregarding the fact that your personal experience is anecdotal nothing you’ve written refutes the body of scientific literature on depression! You might have been prescribed a drug that your body could not use in which case it will do as much for you as a chalk-capsule would.
There are blood tests you can pay for that will give you an indication as to which drugs are likely to have the intended therapeutic response and which will not. These aren’t definitive though. They’re not subsidised by Medicare either so some doctors will simply not mention them and you will get a random antidepressant that might do absolutely nothing for you.
That’s the other thing about depression: there’s no good treatment for it. The drugs are lousy. The disease could be a result of a myriad of different things. An individual with undiagnosed ADHD but is requesting aid for major depression? Treat the ADHD and the depression goes away.
Things aren’t as simple as you angrily and ignorantly claim them to be. A change in diet and an increase in exercise will do as much good as an antidepressant for some people. That’s a truth that sits alongside the fact that diet, exercise and antidepressants all have no positive effect on mood for some individuals. An antidepressant could also be a lifesaver for another. Life’s complicated and that complication doesn’t cease at our skin.
Hang on, I’m confused. I thought you were the other person replying under a different account? You can go check out that thread if you want I guess.
Anyway. I’m not angry or hateful, mate, that’s 100% projection. You’re making a lot of assumptions about me based on a personal opinion. Also, as mentioned in other thread, this was simply my opinion, not a PHD thesis I’m obligated to defend.
If I ignore all the personal attacks and insults in this thread, I actually agree with you. It makes sense to me that maybe just all the people in my circle (myself included) just got ones we couldn’t process. Doctors didn’t tell us anything about this, I didn’t even know that was a thing; and they didn’t offer any additional treatment other than throwing pills at us.
But the way you wrote this… honestly my initial reaction was to want to report/block you, and not read it. I’m glad I did, because there’s actually useful information in there, but c’mon, you can do better.
Just FYI; if you ever feel like other people are “hostile and argumentative” online, I would actually suggest reflecting on your own communication style. Cold starting out with an insult, then sprinkling in needless attacks in your explanation, is honestly just troll behaviour. Nothing in my original comment deserved this kind of abuse.