I think i see the two senses of where the miscommunication occurred.
You can put psychoanalysis in the same bucket at homeopathy in that it doesn’t work when studied by clinical trials, and mainstream practitioners don’t use it.
On the other hand, Freud was not trying to be fraudulent, and did contribute tremendously to the field of psychology, unlike homeopathy’s fraudulent relationship to medicine.
They also teach obsolete models of the atom in science so students understand where we’re coming from, but they don’t still use them.
Not in postgraduate. Which the last comment made pretty clear that, at high levels, Freud is not seen as a complete fraud (mostly).
I have mixed feelings about Lacan, although that’s not my real academic position.
None in postgraduate is looking at old models [of anything] as absolute truths.
I think i see the two senses of where the miscommunication occurred.
You can put psychoanalysis in the same bucket at homeopathy in that it doesn’t work when studied by clinical trials, and mainstream practitioners don’t use it.
On the other hand, Freud was not trying to be fraudulent, and did contribute tremendously to the field of psychology, unlike homeopathy’s fraudulent relationship to medicine.
Exactly that’s the overall sentiment. I personally see it that way too.