I don’t know man causality is a strong word there. At some scales causality doesn’t really mean what it usually means. It doesn’t matter though, entropy will eventually catch up. Slow and steady wins the race.
Oh. That’s fascinating actually. To be clear I wasn’t trying to deride you or anything like that, just genuinely interested in the reasoning other people use when it doesn’t align with my own.
Yes, that’s actually what the original comment was. Someone asked why the comment also said “I was going to say no”, and the same commenter said they’d originally thought radio waves were sound. But they fact checked before ever posting based on that assumption.
Sound is just waves of vibration within the carrier. Because a vacuum is definitely nothing, sound can’t travel through a vacuum.
For contrast, light is both a particle and a wave and is just all sorts of bullshit the more you learn because no seriously what the fuck. But anyways, light can travel through a vacuum because it is the medium it travels through. And it has a different speed outside a vacuum because of interference with other particles, which is how prisms and lenses work.
…i’m trying to visualise this using the little knowledge of relativity that’s still with me from uni.
so sound is a pressure wave, meaning it propagates by particles bumping into one another, which is why it travels faster under water than in air: more particles. using that logic the speed of sound would approach zero as we get closer to perfect vaccum. but if it’s the speed of light, that means you could make a sound and every particle struck by that wave would shoot off at or near the speed of light, giving it effectively infinite energy. you could blow up a planet with a kazoo.
I am genuinely curious about the original grounds on which your “no” was going to be based.
That radio transmissions are sound-based, not light-based, so they use the speed of sound as a baseline instead of the speed of light.
Bro what
eh at least they fact-checked before commenting!
Radio waves are electromagnetic, so speed of causality (or light)
I don’t know man causality is a strong word there. At some scales causality doesn’t really mean what it usually means. It doesn’t matter though, entropy will eventually catch up. Slow and steady wins the race.
In space no one can hear your radio
Major Tom can.
And when they can, it takes forever to get there.
Oh. That’s fascinating actually. To be clear I wasn’t trying to deride you or anything like that, just genuinely interested in the reasoning other people use when it doesn’t align with my own.
No, radio waves are electromagnetic. Sound is a mechanical wave and cannot travel in vacuum (which we assume space to be).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio_wave
Yes, that’s actually what the original comment was. Someone asked why the comment also said “I was going to say no”, and the same commenter said they’d originally thought radio waves were sound. But they fact checked before ever posting based on that assumption.
He’s one of today’s lucky 5!
is there a speed of sound in a vacuum?
Sound is just waves of vibration within the carrier. Because a vacuum is definitely nothing, sound can’t travel through a vacuum.
For contrast, light is both a particle and a wave and is just all sorts of bullshit the more you learn because no seriously what the fuck. But anyways, light can travel through a vacuum because it is the medium it travels through. And it has a different speed outside a vacuum because of interference with other particles, which is how prisms and lenses work.
Maybe it could propagate through the quantum foam! Somehow!
yes, 0. 0 km/h, 0m/s, 0 miles per hour. It just doesn’t reach.
no, sound doesn’t travel in a vacuum
Yes, it’s the speed of light.
…i’m trying to visualise this using the little knowledge of relativity that’s still with me from uni.
so sound is a pressure wave, meaning it propagates by particles bumping into one another, which is why it travels faster under water than in air: more particles. using that logic the speed of sound would approach zero as we get closer to perfect vaccum. but if it’s the speed of light, that means you could make a sound and every particle struck by that wave would shoot off at or near the speed of light, giving it effectively infinite energy. you could blow up a planet with a kazoo.
…i don’t think that’s it.
I mean, the kazoo is a vastly underrated instrument.
add a theremin and you have 60% of the script to a new flash gordon
No, sound is a mechanical wave and cannot travel in vacuum