Fun fact to the commenters here, since it comes up in several: vs random chance, humans detect lies 54% of the time, and no, people trained to detect lies (police, HR, etc) do not do so any better. Usually they overestimate eye contact (that isn’t reliable) and underestimate actual tells, although those are pretty rare if the lie is thought out in advance (e.g. hesitation when coming up with a lie on the spot).
However, we do read body language very well because of this fun little arms race while evolving. People get better at deception, people get better at detecting deception, then people get better at deception further, etc., so we do really have a pretty good sixth sense, in a sense. Evolution that predates humans, even.
If anyone wants, I can probably look up those specific articles, although they’re mostly referenced in the social psych textbook with the class I teach. I find it really fascinating, although they are a bit contracting when they give information on lying body language and then immediately say you can’t detect lies well, lol.
Autistic body language and neurotypical body language do not align at all and I’ve never met a neurotypical individual who has ever read my body language correctly.
Is there anything on women having more developed intuition than men on average? Anecdotally it feels that way. I’ve been called crazy for clocking people to be dishonest years before they openly did something bad. I’ve also gone against my intuition because I wanted to force myself to give people benefit of the doubt, only for my intuition to be right. Meanwhile, my partner and some male friends seem to be less attuned.
Nothing in what I’ve read on this suggested women being any better on average, even if there is a saying about women’s intuition. I can imagine being extra cautious, but that doesn’t necessarily help in accuracy.
That said, maybe there’s an impact of empathy that helps in judging someone’s character long term. Empathy isn’t necessarily gendered, but social norms do push towards men suppressing empathy. But I’m just guessing; men and women are more similar than different until social roles get enforced.
Liars don’t hesitate enough in my experience, but then are scanning for if you detected their lie (so like waiting a bit too much, being very alert, very conscious).
Oh, for sure. Although some autistic folk have good intuition, it’s certainly one of the traits they tend to lack sometimes!
But I mean, normies still only get 54% right on lie detection so what do they even gain. I bet being autistic helps more than hinders at this point given good liars manipulate this stuff.
I am autistic, and have learned the best tactic to lying is, making people believe you are always telling the truth, by being really honest and open about everything. Then, when that rare time you are not, they will believe you.
Lying is usually far too much work and trouble in the end to be worth it anyways, so never doing so except for when it’s actually rarely worth it is just good sense.
Not only will they believe you on the rare occasion you do lie, but you will have so much less bullshit to keep track of.
I always thought the only reliable way to detect lies is to find small inconsistencies and errors in their story. Also people tend to do this specific thing that’s hard to describe. They construct a nice little story, and serve it to you on a platter, like, “here you go - enjoy!” As in, they say the story, and kind of pause unnaturally and try not to add too many details if that makes sense. Like a video game NPC dialogue compared to normal speech
That’s only normal people though. Good liars, there’s no hope. I just assume they’re always lying by reputation lol
Not sure why they’d down vote you; you’re mostly right about the inconsistency or vagueness. Very specific, personal stories tend to be true simply because most people aren’t terribly creative and what little details they might add might get lost in the bs.
Though it cuts both ways… wrong answers also include people who think an answer is a lie when it’s true. Turns out people also misremember and are vague about real life all the time, so it looks like a lie. So while a lie may have inconsistency, it can also just be someone being bad at describing something.
Yeah I guess it’s just mostly up to intuition. Not bulletproof by any means. But you can do stuff like ask for proof if it’s a stranger, or use your prior knowledge about the person if you’re familiar. It’s kind of like trying to tell if an image is A.I. generated nowadays
Ah, haha. And yeah, they never did say anything about reasoning skills and such, but that’s probably harder to study in a simple lab experiment. You’d think professions and training would have some effect though, but then again in the experiments they aren’t doing follow-up questions or using familiar people. It certainly gets more complex when you can investigate farther.
Fun fact to the commenters here, since it comes up in several: vs random chance, humans detect lies 54% of the time, and no, people trained to detect lies (police, HR, etc) do not do so any better. Usually they overestimate eye contact (that isn’t reliable) and underestimate actual tells, although those are pretty rare if the lie is thought out in advance (e.g. hesitation when coming up with a lie on the spot).
However, we do read body language very well because of this fun little arms race while evolving. People get better at deception, people get better at detecting deception, then people get better at deception further, etc., so we do really have a pretty good sixth sense, in a sense. Evolution that predates humans, even.
If anyone wants, I can probably look up those specific articles, although they’re mostly referenced in the social psych textbook with the class I teach. I find it really fascinating, although they are a bit contracting when they give information on lying body language and then immediately say you can’t detect lies well, lol.
Autistic body language and neurotypical body language do not align at all and I’ve never met a neurotypical individual who has ever read my body language correctly.
Is there anything on women having more developed intuition than men on average? Anecdotally it feels that way. I’ve been called crazy for clocking people to be dishonest years before they openly did something bad. I’ve also gone against my intuition because I wanted to force myself to give people benefit of the doubt, only for my intuition to be right. Meanwhile, my partner and some male friends seem to be less attuned.
Nothing in what I’ve read on this suggested women being any better on average, even if there is a saying about women’s intuition. I can imagine being extra cautious, but that doesn’t necessarily help in accuracy.
That said, maybe there’s an impact of empathy that helps in judging someone’s character long term. Empathy isn’t necessarily gendered, but social norms do push towards men suppressing empathy. But I’m just guessing; men and women are more similar than different until social roles get enforced.
Liars don’t hesitate enough in my experience, but then are scanning for if you detected their lie (so like waiting a bit too much, being very alert, very conscious).
Maybe you do. I do not. The autism is real with this one
Oh, for sure. Although some autistic folk have good intuition, it’s certainly one of the traits they tend to lack sometimes!
But I mean, normies still only get 54% right on lie detection so what do they even gain. I bet being autistic helps more than hinders at this point given good liars manipulate this stuff.
I am autistic, and have learned the best tactic to lying is, making people believe you are always telling the truth, by being really honest and open about everything. Then, when that rare time you are not, they will believe you.
Lying is usually far too much work and trouble in the end to be worth it anyways, so never doing so except for when it’s actually rarely worth it is just good sense.
Not only will they believe you on the rare occasion you do lie, but you will have so much less bullshit to keep track of.
I always thought the only reliable way to detect lies is to find small inconsistencies and errors in their story. Also people tend to do this specific thing that’s hard to describe. They construct a nice little story, and serve it to you on a platter, like, “here you go - enjoy!” As in, they say the story, and kind of pause unnaturally and try not to add too many details if that makes sense. Like a video game NPC dialogue compared to normal speech
That’s only normal people though. Good liars, there’s no hope. I just assume they’re always lying by reputation lol
Not sure why they’d down vote you; you’re mostly right about the inconsistency or vagueness. Very specific, personal stories tend to be true simply because most people aren’t terribly creative and what little details they might add might get lost in the bs.
Though it cuts both ways… wrong answers also include people who think an answer is a lie when it’s true. Turns out people also misremember and are vague about real life all the time, so it looks like a lie. So while a lie may have inconsistency, it can also just be someone being bad at describing something.
I remove my own upvotes lol
Yeah I guess it’s just mostly up to intuition. Not bulletproof by any means. But you can do stuff like ask for proof if it’s a stranger, or use your prior knowledge about the person if you’re familiar. It’s kind of like trying to tell if an image is A.I. generated nowadays
Ah, haha. And yeah, they never did say anything about reasoning skills and such, but that’s probably harder to study in a simple lab experiment. You’d think professions and training would have some effect though, but then again in the experiments they aren’t doing follow-up questions or using familiar people. It certainly gets more complex when you can investigate farther.