Those ideas were not just made up, they evolved for rational reasons. Seemingly overnight, we had a vast continent to conquer.
A man had to grow his own food and defend his family against other humans who disputed who’s continent it was. A man had no one but his family to depend on, if that. Under attack? Wolves ravaging your animals? Broken bone or fever? Busted equipement? 100% on you, no 911, no Home Depot, no neighbors for miles, if you had neighbors at all. No one is going to save you but you.
If you live in the country, much of that still applies, although to a lesser degree. A small example from my own life: At my camp in the boonies, the dirt roads are private. Not to say blocked off, but the county isn’t going to touch them. It’s up to us to maintain them, however we can. There’s no government to complain to, no one responsible but whoever can help.
I don’t think Europeans and American city folks can truly get their heads around this. They’ve never been without a working water or sewage system that a phone call couldn’t fix. They’ve never been so far out in the boondocks alone that rescue wasn’t an option. They’ve never been out of 911 range. So, like you, they think it’s made up from whole cloth or was confabulated by Hollywood.
Have those tropes poisoned the American idea of masculinity? Certainly! But these tropes exist because they were and are real.
Those ideas were not just made up, they evolved for rational reasons. Seemingly overnight, we had a vast continent to conquer.
A man had to grow his own food and defend his family against other humans who disputed who’s continent it was. A man had no one but his family to depend on, if that. Under attack? Wolves ravaging your animals? Broken bone or fever? Busted equipement? 100% on you, no 911, no Home Depot, no neighbors for miles, if you had neighbors at all. No one is going to save you but you.
If you live in the country, much of that still applies, although to a lesser degree. A small example from my own life: At my camp in the boonies, the dirt roads are private. Not to say blocked off, but the county isn’t going to touch them. It’s up to us to maintain them, however we can. There’s no government to complain to, no one responsible but whoever can help.
I don’t think Europeans and American city folks can truly get their heads around this. They’ve never been without a working water or sewage system that a phone call couldn’t fix. They’ve never been so far out in the boondocks alone that rescue wasn’t an option. They’ve never been out of 911 range. So, like you, they think it’s made up from whole cloth or was confabulated by Hollywood.
Have those tropes poisoned the American idea of masculinity? Certainly! But these tropes exist because they were and are real.