• FreedomAdvocate
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    arrow-down
    8
    ·
    6 hours ago

    People like you wouldn’t have seen the benefit in cars vs horse and carriages, computers vs typewriters and books, or watches vs sundials.

    I bet you think that the only thing AI is used for is ChatGPT style conversations too.

    • very_well_lost@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      32 minutes ago

      wouldn’t have seen the benefit in cars

      Yeah, because the widespread adoption of cars turned out to be such a great idea with no negative consequences… But even if you ignore the glaringly obvious negatives, AI still doesn’t come anywhere close to having the practical utility as the modern car. At least a car can carry out its advertised function without issues.

      I’ve been using AI almost daily for several years now, as a function of my job. It’s garbage tech. Most of the things it’s supposed to be good for it downright sucks at, and the stuff it is good at has already been possible using simpler, more reliable systems for years — sometimes even decades. The situation isn’t really improving, either. Models are using more energy, consuming more data, and doing more computation than ever before… but the results are still embarrassingly underwhelming. Anyone who’s bothered to educate themselves on the math and method behind the models knows by now that the current generation of AI is dead-end technology, and anyone who claims otherwise is either ignorant of the technical details, has a vested financial interest in AI, or both.

      It also really fucking irritates me to be constantly called a Luddite by people who don’t even know how this technology fucking works… No, I don’t hate AI because I’m scared of technology, or “progress” or whatever the fuck. I’ve made a career working in technology. I love tech… or I used to, before everyone lost their god damn minds praying to Sam Altman and his horrifyingly expensive golden idol. No, I hate AI because it’s demonstrably bad technology.

    • leftthegroup@lemmings.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      6
      ·
      5 hours ago

      Theoretically, sure there’s potential. But it shouldn’t be getting used as a commercial product in the meantime.

      Especially generative. Letting it write, compose, create… All of that is 1,000% a mistake. The kind accessible to the public can’t currently create at scale without unethical access to source material.

      It shouldn’t be getting shoehorned into every job possible while it’s still in this pre-alpha kind of state.

      Although I don’t actually know the ratio of research use vs casual use, tbf. But this shit gotta be litigated and used properly with proper guidelines, not just thrown out like this.

      It’s still way too early for this shit. Our willingness as a species to just jump into new tech should have been tempered to be smarter by now.

      Maybe I would’ve been reluctant about those technologies. But I am convinced with data. And so far I’ve only seen problems with it, no actual benefits.