I’d argue that anyone who claims that taking a stance against genocide is anti-Semitic, is the one being anti-Semitic…
Why? Because that claim essentially equates claiming that Semitic people have a right to genocide, or it’s an inherent behaviour of Semitic people, thus it’s anti-Semitic.
Calling yourself Semitic is like calling yourself Aryan. Claiming relations to a long dead culture through genetics in order to claim “ancestral land”.
There’s also the fact that the people who actually match the general genetic profile of the ancient inhabitants of the area are the Palestinians, not the Israeli colonizers.
Not really, Semitic peoples is an exonym coming from the name Shem from the bible used to describe many cultures from the fertile cresent and surrounding areas that share similar cultural and languages, this would include Arabic, Aramaic, Hebrew, Berber, Egyptian, Coptic, Phoenician, and Cananite languages at a minimum. In more common terms semeticic and specifically anti-semitism has become associated with Judaism specifically as many large scale antisemitic movements (against Jews specifically) in the second half of the 20th century took place in the middle east in what could be called Semitic countries for cultural similarity. This foes not excuse the current outcomes of the slaughter going on but context will help understand what is going on and why which makes things easier to change, and false facts or propaganda doesn’t help solve that.
I’d argue that anyone who claims that taking a stance against genocide is anti-Semitic, is the one being anti-Semitic…
Why? Because that claim essentially equates claiming that Semitic people have a right to genocide, or it’s an inherent behaviour of Semitic people, thus it’s anti-Semitic.
Calling yourself Semitic is like calling yourself Aryan. Claiming relations to a long dead culture through genetics in order to claim “ancestral land”.
There’s also the fact that the people who actually match the general genetic profile of the ancient inhabitants of the area are the Palestinians, not the Israeli colonizers.
Unless they mean “speakers of Semitic languages” in which case all Arabic people would be included too.
Not really, Semitic peoples is an exonym coming from the name Shem from the bible used to describe many cultures from the fertile cresent and surrounding areas that share similar cultural and languages, this would include Arabic, Aramaic, Hebrew, Berber, Egyptian, Coptic, Phoenician, and Cananite languages at a minimum. In more common terms semeticic and specifically anti-semitism has become associated with Judaism specifically as many large scale antisemitic movements (against Jews specifically) in the second half of the 20th century took place in the middle east in what could be called Semitic countries for cultural similarity. This foes not excuse the current outcomes of the slaughter going on but context will help understand what is going on and why which makes things easier to change, and false facts or propaganda doesn’t help solve that.
That and the Palestinians are Semitic people too