Boeing and Lockheed Martin's rocket venture suffered its first mission failure when a Vulcan rocket carrying 40 Amazon Leo satellites failed to reach orbit.
The Amazon satellites are a competitor to Musk’s Starlink. It would be good for the world for Elon not to have a monopoly on low cost globally accessible high speed internet.
The problem is that there are pressing uses where you’d want internet satellites. Disaster relief is a big one, but also it’s one way to get around internet censorship in authoritarian states. Also Ukraine is using them so that’s gotta count for something.
Interestingly enough, the dude who was SpaceX’s general council has a new startup competitor to star link (out of Switzerland) that is specifically trying to make a “sovereign internet” in LEO for governments. Think Ukraine and what they’ve been dealing with.
Bite the bullet, and build out fiber like we should have ages ago. Stop pulling money legislated to the fiber build out to companies like Starlink. Putting a new fleet of satellites in orbit just for them to burn up every 5-6 years doesn’t make sense in the long run.
Right, I should individually pay 2 million dollars (quote from 2017) to run fiber to my house since they decided the fiber should end a quarter mile away. What a wonderful solution.
The solution you’re providing is just addressing the problem of remote high speed internet in the USA. That does nothing to address users in the rest of the world.
I’m simply suggesting that we not pollute the sky with satellites.
Okay, so your argument isn’t against internet satellites specifically, but any human-made satellite? There were already over 6000 active satellites in orbit before Musk launched his first Starlink satellite. You would want those gone too, right?
Okay, so your argument isn’t against internet satellites specifically, but any human-made satellite?
Starlink currently has 9800+ satellites, which is 1.6x that 6000 figure you cited. For one single company.
What @dohpaz42@lemmy.world is clearly suggesting isn’t “no satellites at all” (they can correct me if I’m wrong) but that we as humans shouldn’t be racing to utterly blanket the Earth’s orbit with a shitload of satellites for any company that decides they want their own satellite Internet constellation.
You’re either extremely disingenuous or exhibiting really poor reading comprehension that you’re interpreting what they’re suggesting as “zero satellites”.
Every satellite, space probe, and crewed mission has the potential to produce space debris. The theoretical cascading Kessler syndrome becomes more likely as satellites in orbit increase in number. In 2025 the number was estimated at over 11,800,[24] most of which (7,135) belonged to Starlink, the constellation of SpaceX.[25] As of 2021, it was estimated that there were 600,000 pieces of space junk ranging from 1 to 10 cm (1⁄2 to 4 in), and 23,000 larger than that.[26] On average, every year, one satellite is destroyed by collision with other satellites or space junk.[27
You’re either extremely disingenuous or exhibiting really poor reading comprehension that you’re interpreting what they’re suggesting as “zero satellites”.
I’m asking good faith questions. I refuse to strawman @dohpaz42@lemmy.world and put words in their mouth. However, their responses are pretty vague and I’m trying to get clarity on their position.
Starlink currently has 9800+ satellites, which is 1.6x that 6000 figure you cited. For one single company.
From my understanding of their position even 1 is too many.
As to continuing with you on the topic, given you’ve only allowed your two options for your reading of my questions and both of those barbs, I don’t have any faith that we’d have a pleasant or useful conversation, so I’ll end ours here while we’re still bordering on friendly.
Building out and maintaining fiber to all remote users in the entire world would be astronomically expensive! Probably more expensive than the all of the top one hundred most expensive works projects in the world combined just to build it out. Then the huge cost of maintaining it.
The longest distance you can run a piece of fiber without a repeater is 100km max. So your suggestion means installing hundreds of thousands of fiber repeaters in some of the most remote place on Earth. Keep in mind, what you’re suggesting would have us running fiber to Antarctica too.
Who is paying for all of that one-time and ongoing costs?
unfortunately not everyone can live without satellite internet. for example, ukrainians die every time musk cuts off the starlink connection used to defend them.
we’re not talking about a toy for rich people. it’s basic infrastructure.
You’re aware that Russia has used Starlink to drive their own military invasion for almost all of the Ukraine invasion (all the way to Feb of this year)? It’s a double-edged sword.
Additionally, Musk has been using Starlink to drive political ends by disabling or slowing access for Ukraine at will thoughout the conflict. Governments should be implementing satellites networks for defence - not goddamn Musk.
Take away Starlink, and Russia and Ukraine both lose access and go back to prior methods, and also deny a privately-owned business run by an incredibly unscrupulous billionaire from wielding geopolitical power. This is all not a bad thing.
Okay, your complaint is different than @dohpaz42@lemmy.world . They are against all satellites, not just internet serving ones. I’m comfortable with exploring your argument too as a separate line of thought though if you like.
Can I assume you have non-satellite based high speed internet likely from living in a higher population density municipality?
It’s always nice to hear some good news for a change.
The Amazon satellites are a competitor to Musk’s Starlink. It would be good for the world for Elon not to have a monopoly on low cost globally accessible high speed internet.
Yeah, no. You’re going in the wrong direction with that line of thinking. We need less internet satellites, not more. Zero would be ideal.
The problem is that there are pressing uses where you’d want internet satellites. Disaster relief is a big one, but also it’s one way to get around internet censorship in authoritarian states. Also Ukraine is using them so that’s gotta count for something.
Interestingly enough, the dude who was SpaceX’s general council has a new startup competitor to star link (out of Switzerland) that is specifically trying to make a “sovereign internet” in LEO for governments. Think Ukraine and what they’ve been dealing with.
easy to say when you are connected in a more populated, non-war city with functional internet and it isnt your life at stake.
What are you recommending for a high speed internet solution for billions of people in the world that don’t live on a fiber ring?
Bite the bullet, and build out fiber like we should have ages ago. Stop pulling money legislated to the fiber build out to companies like Starlink. Putting a new fleet of satellites in orbit just for them to burn up every 5-6 years doesn’t make sense in the long run.
How are we gonna string fiber to, e.g., ships at sea?
very long ethernet cables, obviously
the stench of classism and privilege is pungent in here.
Right, I should individually pay 2 million dollars (quote from 2017) to run fiber to my house since they decided the fiber should end a quarter mile away. What a wonderful solution.
The solution you’re providing is just addressing the problem of remote high speed internet in the USA. That does nothing to address users in the rest of the world.
Should we focus on providing high speed internet to starving Africans or shit they need more like food and water?
I’m not. I’m simply suggesting that we not pollute the sky with satellites.
Okay, so your argument isn’t against internet satellites specifically, but any human-made satellite? There were already over 6000 active satellites in orbit before Musk launched his first Starlink satellite. You would want those gone too, right?
Starlink currently has 9800+ satellites, which is 1.6x that 6000 figure you cited. For one single company.
What @dohpaz42@lemmy.world is clearly suggesting isn’t “no satellites at all” (they can correct me if I’m wrong) but that we as humans shouldn’t be racing to utterly blanket the Earth’s orbit with a shitload of satellites for any company that decides they want their own satellite Internet constellation.
You’re either extremely disingenuous or exhibiting really poor reading comprehension that you’re interpreting what they’re suggesting as “zero satellites”.
I’ll just leave this “fun” Supplementary reading here
Kessler syndrome - Wikipedia https://share.google/e50slyVgNvUmvu5JG
Excerpt:
Every satellite, space probe, and crewed mission has the potential to produce space debris. The theoretical cascading Kessler syndrome becomes more likely as satellites in orbit increase in number. In 2025 the number was estimated at over 11,800,[24] most of which (7,135) belonged to Starlink, the constellation of SpaceX.[25] As of 2021, it was estimated that there were 600,000 pieces of space junk ranging from 1 to 10 cm (1⁄2 to 4 in), and 23,000 larger than that.[26] On average, every year, one satellite is destroyed by collision with other satellites or space junk.[27
You’re not going to win a lot of friends here by using a share.google link for no reason. Here’s the actual URL:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kessler_syndrome
I’m asking good faith questions. I refuse to strawman @dohpaz42@lemmy.world and put words in their mouth. However, their responses are pretty vague and I’m trying to get clarity on their position.
From my understanding of their position even 1 is too many.
As to continuing with you on the topic, given you’ve only allowed your two options for your reading of my questions and both of those barbs, I don’t have any faith that we’d have a pleasant or useful conversation, so I’ll end ours here while we’re still bordering on friendly.
This is nothing but a False Dichotomy. Clearly that is not what dohpaz42 meant.
I would recommend we get them fiber
Building out and maintaining fiber to all remote users in the entire world would be astronomically expensive! Probably more expensive than the all of the top one hundred most expensive works projects in the world combined just to build it out. Then the huge cost of maintaining it.
The longest distance you can run a piece of fiber without a repeater is 100km max. So your suggestion means installing hundreds of thousands of fiber repeaters in some of the most remote place on Earth. Keep in mind, what you’re suggesting would have us running fiber to Antarctica too.
Who is paying for all of that one-time and ongoing costs?
Kessler syndrome will be more expensive
Brother, we don’t need gaming latency in deserts and the antarctic…
You think satellite launches are maintenance free and cheap, or is this some sort of long form of sarcasm?
I recommend they can live without one, as they did prior to Starlink.
The pollution to LEO, the ionosphere, and the night sky are not worth it.
unfortunately not everyone can live without satellite internet. for example, ukrainians die every time musk cuts off the starlink connection used to defend them.
we’re not talking about a toy for rich people. it’s basic infrastructure.
You’re aware that Russia has used Starlink to drive their own military invasion for almost all of the Ukraine invasion (all the way to Feb of this year)? It’s a double-edged sword.
Additionally, Musk has been using Starlink to drive political ends by disabling or slowing access for Ukraine at will thoughout the conflict. Governments should be implementing satellites networks for defence - not goddamn Musk.
Take away Starlink, and Russia and Ukraine both lose access and go back to prior methods, and also deny a privately-owned business run by an incredibly unscrupulous billionaire from wielding geopolitical power. This is all not a bad thing.
https://www.cnn.com/2026/01/29/europe/russia-starlink-drones
Satellite Internet existed long before Amazon and Starlink.
deleted by creator
Okay, your complaint is different than @dohpaz42@lemmy.world . They are against all satellites, not just internet serving ones. I’m comfortable with exploring your argument too as a separate line of thought though if you like.
Can I assume you have non-satellite based high speed internet likely from living in a higher population density municipality?