• 87 Posts
  • 765 Comments
Joined 7 years ago
cake
Cake day: April 17th, 2019

help-circle


  • Dessalines@lemmy.mltoMemes@lemmy.mlLiterally
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    Its probably a decade old meme at this point, which is besides the point, and is why you dodged the content of the meme. No revolution will ever meet your standards. Millions of people are too busy building socialism and lifting people out of poverty to care what some western anarchist thinks about them.















  • Do you think this could become popular enough it to be useful?

    Everything starts from zero, so really it just requires a push for the project to get started.

    Public BitTorrent trackers for other media are barely seeded as it is and they have been active for decades.

    I don’t think I agree with this. Many torrents have thousands of seeders, and even if I search for old movies, I can find ones with at least a handful of seeders. Given the popularity of youtube videos, its possible that people would seed their favorites if they have the possibility to do so.

    Actually considering the db is just one massive torrent.csv file I guess you can’t really sensor that.

    Yep, its kinda wild, that the entire index of popular torrents (which equates to most popular media humankind has created), fits in a CSV file of less than 200MB. Makes it pretty hard to censor in that case.



  • To truly decentralize the metadata layer, consider whether the search infrastructure itself can be federated or if the client should handle local indexing to eliminate dependency on any external discovery service.

    A federated search service / index (especially unmoderated) could quickly fill up with spam. So at least the torrent additions / adders themselves need to be vetted and trustworthy for a search to work correctly.

    And of course torrents-csv doesn’t have to be the only place hosting magnet links. They could easily be posted to any federated app, like a lemmy community or mastodon also.




  • Why should I use this over yt-dlp, Piped, Invidious, etc?

    None of those are attempts to decentralize youtube. Piped and invidious are only front ends for youtube, which can easily be blocked by youtube at any moment, which has happened in the case of tons of third party clients.

    yt-dlp is a very useful tool (which this projects uses), to download youtube videos. It does not help collectively share them, as torrents would.

    What does this do differently than the other projects?

    Peertube and other youtube alternatives are based on centralized hosting. This is completely unsustainable, because the HD space required for servers quickly grows out of hand, and becomes extremely expensive. Meanwhile, torrents are shared hosting, where many people are sharing files at once. It is the main way large files like movies are distributed over the internet, for decades now. We should apply that same effort to creating torrents for youtube videos, in the same way that is already done for other large files.